House Passes Gosar-Pearce Amendment Allowing for Responsible State Management of Mexican Wolf Populations

Jul 14, 2016 Issues: Government Oversight and Regulatory Reform, Energy, Public Lands and Water

For Immediate Release

Date: July 14, 2016

Contact: Steven D. Smith


WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, Congressman Paul A. Gosar, D.D.S. (AZ-04) released the following statement after the House passed the Gosar/Pearce amendment by a vote of 219-203 allowing for the responsible state management of the Mexican Wolf and successfully attached the amendment to the Department of Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2017:

“The Federal approach to managing the Mexican Wolf has been a lose/lose situation for everyone involved. Farmers, ranchers and families in New Mexico and Arizona face longer wait times for wolf disturbances and the species itself has seen its numbers decline under the flawed management of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). Allowing States to responsibly manage the species back into recovery is a no-brainer. The status quo has resulted in the Mexican Wolf lingering on the Endangered Species list for 40 years. States have proven better at species conservation and management than a bloated bureaucracy that only responds to frivolous lawsuits.”

Following passage of the amendment, Congressman Steve Pearce (NV-02) stated, “FWS has consistently proven its inability to manage the Mexican Wolf program in New Mexico. This is clear in the recent Inspector General Report substantiating claims from Catron County that those at the top levels of the program at FWS tolerated a culture of lies, falsification, mismanagement and manipulation of scientific data, ultimately at the cost of public trust and species recovery.  I am pleased that the House passed this amendment. It is time to give this program back to the States.”


The full text of the amendment can be found HERE.

One of the main issues for wolf recovery is an extremely outdated recovery plan being utilized by FWS. The Mexican wolf was first listed as an endangered species in 1976. In 1982, Mexico and the United States signed the Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan, which FWS is still currently utilizing today. As a result, this plan is significantly outdated and is not based on the best available science.

In January 2015, FWS drastically increased the recovery range for the wolves without requesting the proper resources needed to manage the program. Later that year in December 2015, FWS confirmed that the agency was again considering introducing the species into areas outside its historic range. This expansion effort is extremely misguided as 90% of the Mexican’s wolf’s historic range is in Mexico. The four Governors from the states of Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Utah sent a bipartisan letter to Department of Interior Secretary Sally Jewell expressing serious concerns and opposition to this approach.

To make matters worse, just this week, the Department of the Interior’s Office of Inspector General released a scathing report of the Mexican Gray Wolf Recovery Program. The report revealed some serious structural issues with the program as well as disturbing actions taken by FWS staff overseeing the program.

On June 8, 2015, the Arizona Attorney General and the Arizona Game and Fish Department filed a lawsuit against the secretary of the Department of Interior and FWS “for failing their statutory duty to develop an updated recovery plan to guide Mexican wolf recovery.” In April 2016, the New Mexico Department of Game and Fish also filed a lawsuit against FWS, claiming that the agency was ignoring the “laws and regulations of New Mexico” by releasing wolves without state permits. In June, a federal judge sided with the New Mexico State government and granted the state a temporary injunction preventing the FWS from releasing any more Mexican wolves into the wild.

Endorsements of the successful amendment included: American Farm Bureau Federation; Americans for Limited Government; the Public Lands Council; the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association; Arizona Cattle Feeders Association; Arizona Farm Bureau Federation; Arizona Liberty; Action Analysis Partners, LLC; Concerned Citizens for America Arizona Chapter; Cedar Hills Electric; Dona Ana Soil and Water Conservation District; Gila County Cattle Growers’ Association; Idaho Recreation Council; M bar K Cattle Co.; Maricopa County Cattle Growers’ Association; Mule Shoe X Cattle co; Multiple Land Use and Access of Arizona/New Mexico; New Mexico Cattle Growers’ Association; New Mexico Wool Growers, Inc.; New Mexico Federal Lands Council; OC Ranch Management; Payson Hoseman's Association; Potato Butte Ranch; Rafter P Ranch; Veritas Research; Yavapai Cattle Growers’ Association; Arizona State Representative Bob Thorpe; Apache County District 3 Supervisor Barry Weller; Yavapai County Supervisor District 3 Chip Davis; Hidalgo County Commissioner Darr Shannon; Wildlife biologist Mary Darling; Taxpayers John Fowler, James Goughnour, Gary Kiehne, Therese Griffin Hicks, Becky Nutt, Peter Oddonetto and Jim and Sue Chilton.